Question about Extended Warranty
#21
I would never buy an extended warranty on a Honda. When have you ever heard of a failure between 36k and 100k miles that would have made the warranty worth it, or a situation in which honda corporate would not have good-willed the major portion of the failure (i.e. total transmission failures on Honda Odysseys up until 100k (and longer) miles even if you only had a 36k factory warranty).
Heck on Toyota they don't even honor their factory 60k warranty in my experience, wanting to charge me hundreds to clean or replace the IAC valve on our Rav4 even though failure to idle should have been covered!
Heck on Toyota they don't even honor their factory 60k warranty in my experience, wanting to charge me hundreds to clean or replace the IAC valve on our Rav4 even though failure to idle should have been covered!
#22
Hondas are great cars but are not infallible and granted, most issues will happen under warranty but not all issues (including major ones) will be covered by Honda. One thing that hasn't been mentioned(or at least I didn't see it) is that the factory warranty also includes roadside assistance and other perks usually only associated with 3rd party programs like AAA. so or us, for about $13/month I not only have AAA-like coverage, but have full coverage in the even of some failure happening. Granted I may never make back the $1000 (and I hope I don't) but $13 a month for "insurance" for a family on a budget is MUCH more palatable than a $1000 repair bill required in lump sum when the repair is due. And, I'll have a rental while the repairs are done.
~SB
~SB
#23
If you had an example of any Honda failures that were not good-willed please let me know as I am open minded to evidence to the contrary.
#24
My car insurance offers roadside assistance for ~12 bucks a year. Paying 13 month for that seems a bit overpriced.
And really, if you rolled the warranty into the loan, you'd have been better off not getting the warranty and putting that cash into a savings account to save for future repairs.
And really, if you rolled the warranty into the loan, you'd have been better off not getting the warranty and putting that cash into a savings account to save for future repairs.
#25
I see it a totally different way. If you are a family on a budget you are being reckless with your money throwing 1000 based on your insecurity and feelings rather than a real issue.
If you had an example of any Honda failures that were not good-willed please let me know as I am open minded to evidence to the contrary.
If you had an example of any Honda failures that were not good-willed please let me know as I am open minded to evidence to the contrary.
A lot of people spend money on peace of mind in the form of insurance. The insurance companies are always going to make a profit. How much this peace of mind is worth is entirely subjective.
My wife bought the warranty on her car (pontiac, yeesh). I didn't argue, except to state I didn't think it was worth it. If I had, I never would have heard the end of it. Sometimes peace of mind is priceless.
Most small stuff (electronics) will fail within the 36month/36k. Most other stuff will wait until after 150K to go bad (radiators, water pumps, alternators, starters, CV joints, A/C, etc.). My insurance was buying a Honda and not a Kia or Hyundai.
#26
Compare this to car insurance. Major car crashes are pretty rare, unpredictable, if there are medical issues or you hit a fancy car they can be extremely costly, etc.
#28
I almost never buy extended warranty. But $8.95 a month? Gotta think about it. Especially if you are from the school of the mechanically declined or just don't have the time or inclination to play with a car!
Google search turns up less than 100% dependability, very high rate but still not 100%
If you think its worth it buy it, I'm still on the fence!
AT my age I am not concerned about the money quadrupling by the time I retire, 13 years too late!
JIm 0311
- #1: power steering failure on the 2007 FIT
- Number of Complaints: 4
- Average Cost to Fix: $800
- Average Mileage: 56,875 mi
Google search turns up less than 100% dependability, very high rate but still not 100%
If you think its worth it buy it, I'm still on the fence!
AT my age I am not concerned about the money quadrupling by the time I retire, 13 years too late!
JIm 0311
#29
I almost never buy extended warranty. But $8.95 a month? Gotta think about it. Especially if you are from the school of the mechanically declined or just don't have the time or inclination to play with a car!
Google search turns up less than 100% dependability, very high rate but still not 100%
If you think its worth it buy it, I'm still on the fence!
AT my age I am not concerned about the money quadrupling by the time I retire, 13 years too late!
JIm 0311
- #1: power steering failure on the 2007 FIT
- Number of Complaints: 4
- Average Cost to Fix: $800
- Average Mileage: 56,875 mi
Google search turns up less than 100% dependability, very high rate but still not 100%
If you think its worth it buy it, I'm still on the fence!
AT my age I am not concerned about the money quadrupling by the time I retire, 13 years too late!
JIm 0311
#30
At $1600 I agree with you. At $860 I'm on fence! If I had to pay $1600 for the warranty, with the price of used Fits, I would do a private sale in two years and spend the $1600 on a new one.
If I decide to keep car I will go for the warranty.
I also carry car and health insurance, homeowners, and flood. I also have ERS, used it 3 times in 10 years!
JIm 0311
If I decide to keep car I will go for the warranty.
I also carry car and health insurance, homeowners, and flood. I also have ERS, used it 3 times in 10 years!
JIm 0311
#31
I also carry car and health insurance, homeowners, and flood. I also have ERS, used it 3 times in 10 years!
JIm 0311
JIm 0311
In the age of smartphones, I'm not sure that roadside assistance makes as much sense as it used to. But the cost of it is so cheap (10-20/year) that its not worth nitpicking over.
#32
Brakes are a common out of warranty repair usually in the neighborhood of $400-$600, and that is usually an item which MANY cars have to deal with. I had to have a caliper replaced on one of my integras and that was about $400 including two rotors, then if you have an issue like the one above... another $800, that's $1200 for a $860 warranty. Then there are other issues which may creep up. Honda makes a good car but when you rely on that vehicle, spending a few $$ extra every month to ensure you will have nothing to worry about is worth it.
As for the Roadside assistance, I'm not paying $13 for strictly roadside assistance, it comes with the extended warranty which covers many items including calipers, the water pump, cv joints, Clutch, etc... all of which can get to be expensive.
With a family, having a vehicle that can get me to and from work when I need it is of prime importance. Doing what seems financially sound for the long run isn't always what is BEST.
~SB
As for the Roadside assistance, I'm not paying $13 for strictly roadside assistance, it comes with the extended warranty which covers many items including calipers, the water pump, cv joints, Clutch, etc... all of which can get to be expensive.
With a family, having a vehicle that can get me to and from work when I need it is of prime importance. Doing what seems financially sound for the long run isn't always what is BEST.
~SB
#33
[quote=specboy;1003325]
With a family, having a vehicle that can get me to and from work when I need it is of prime importance. Doing what seems financially sound for the long run isn't always what is BEST.
~SB[/quote
Very well put. Shot myself in the foot many times trying to do what was the best move.
Penny wise and pound foolish is what the old people called it! JIm 0311
With a family, having a vehicle that can get me to and from work when I need it is of prime importance. Doing what seems financially sound for the long run isn't always what is BEST.
~SB[/quote
Very well put. Shot myself in the foot many times trying to do what was the best move.
Penny wise and pound foolish is what the old people called it! JIm 0311
#34
Penny wise and pound foolish is what the old people called it! JIm 0311
Warranties aren't for everyone but a blanket statement saying they are not worth getting isn't accurate. They have value for many.
~SB
#35
Normal things that will fail, like shocks, spark plugs, motor mounts, etc, get categorized as wear items so you will pay whether you have the warranty or not.
For most, you are paying for peace-of-mind but you only receive the idea and nothing more. One of my friends, that I nick-named "spender," always gets the extended warranty and then trades in the car within 2 years. That happens often enough to make a lot of happy dealerships
Last edited by jondotcom; 06-14-2011 at 12:10 AM.
#36
The house odds on craps can be as low as 3%, if I remember right, depending on how you play/bet. On roulette it's around 6% if they have both 0 and 00 on the wheel.
The profit margin on a life insurance policy is pretty low, same goes for car insurance. For an extended warranty, that's not price-regulated by any state that I know of, the profit margin is huge, and that's ignoring administrative and marketing costs. The reason the dealer pushes it so hard is that the dealer gets paid money to sell the warranty, and they're not the only ones making a profit from it.
Buy it if you want, but from an economic point of view it's a bad bet because other people, on the other side of the bet, are making money.
The profit margin on a life insurance policy is pretty low, same goes for car insurance. For an extended warranty, that's not price-regulated by any state that I know of, the profit margin is huge, and that's ignoring administrative and marketing costs. The reason the dealer pushes it so hard is that the dealer gets paid money to sell the warranty, and they're not the only ones making a profit from it.
Buy it if you want, but from an economic point of view it's a bad bet because other people, on the other side of the bet, are making money.
#37
LIve long and prosper JIm 0311
#38
Hope you don't think I made a blanket statement, but one within the context of this particular make of car. I have owned ~10+ honda/acura products over the years and currently own two. One of them is a 2nd-gen Honda Odyssey which has been on the road for 150k miles and is 10 years old. This Odyssey is one of the least reliable vehicles (in honda terms) that Honda has produced recently, and it only was purchased with the 3yr/36k factory warranty. It had a transmission failure right at 100k miles and Honda good-will warrantied it! Other known failures were recalled because they are safety items (most are!) and replaced for free, such as the ignition switch. You are right that in the rarest of rare instances, the warranty might be worth it (saving you a call to honda corporate, etc). The real issue is that the dealer will try to make a buck whether you have the warranty or not, and you always need to be proactive if they are talking about charging you anything.
Normal things that will fail, like shocks, spark plugs, motor mounts, etc, get categorized as wear items so you will pay whether you have the warranty or not.
For most, you are paying for peace-of-mind but you only receive the idea and nothing more. One of my friends, that I nick-named "spender," always gets the extended warranty and then trades in the car within 2 years. That happens often enough to make a lot of happy dealerships
Normal things that will fail, like shocks, spark plugs, motor mounts, etc, get categorized as wear items so you will pay whether you have the warranty or not.
For most, you are paying for peace-of-mind but you only receive the idea and nothing more. One of my friends, that I nick-named "spender," always gets the extended warranty and then trades in the car within 2 years. That happens often enough to make a lot of happy dealerships
Warranties, like auto insurance are all about what-if's and peace of mind. I've had a few Hondas in my day as well (2 integras, a prelude, civic, Ridgeline) and have had a few repairs that have cost hundreds. As I mentioned before the Ridgeline had brake issues where I had to have a caliper and both rear rotors replaced at right around $600. Had the Ridge not been under warranty, I'd been out $600. My prelude had a clutch failure which cost me $400. My Integra Distributor Siezed which locked up the timing belt. Fortunately, it didn't destroy the engine and the timingbelt, distributor, (and I opted for the water pump at that time). The whole thing was over $900 which Acura picked up half the tab.
During all of these issues, I was lucky that I was still living near my parents house (or in college) and could barrow my Parents Van or else I would have been out for Rental vehicle costs as well.
What if the Odyssey Transmission hadn't been good willed? Should we be Expecting that Honda will always good will everything major? That's not a smart move when you have to ensure that you can put food on the table for a 4 year old.
Like I said, warranties are not for everyone but they are for some.
~SB
#39
Yes, the extended warrantees are good for those who might suffer a loss greater than the cost of the warranty. And a bad bet for everyone else.
But since none of us can predict the future and know who will be in which category in the future... economically it's a bad bet. Insurance is for losses too great to bear the risk of, like fire insurance on your house. Whether a couple of thousand dollars is that big a loss for you depends upon your economic situation, but over your lifetime you'll spend a lot more on extended warrantees than you ever will on repairs, unless you've got really bad luck.
But since none of us can predict the future and know who will be in which category in the future... economically it's a bad bet. Insurance is for losses too great to bear the risk of, like fire insurance on your house. Whether a couple of thousand dollars is that big a loss for you depends upon your economic situation, but over your lifetime you'll spend a lot more on extended warrantees than you ever will on repairs, unless you've got really bad luck.
#40
Also, what's this whole per month thing? Are people really borrowing money to pay for an extended warranty?