09 fit manual or auto????
#4
I gotta have a manual. Especially from Honda. They are always silky smooth and a joy to drive. I don't like automatics; it's like driving a bumper car. As of today, I won't even consider the car if it doesn't come in Manual. I think the whole Automatic Transmission with those paddles is beyond stupid. But to each his/her own.
I'm dreading the future if a Hybrid is the only car one can buy because so far it appears Hybrids only come with Automatic Transmissions.
I'm dreading the future if a Hybrid is the only car one can buy because so far it appears Hybrids only come with Automatic Transmissions.
#6
I agree
I test drove the 2007 Fit way back in 2006 - July (Auto) , August (5spd & auto again for comparison). I can't get used to the paddles, and don't like the feel of the auto. The 5 speed is more to my liking, probably cause I've been mainly driving manual cars for 20yrs. To each his/her own.
I would have bought the 07 Fit but couldnt get the deal I wanted, and I was frustrated with the majority of the dealerships mistruths. Thanks to fitfreak.net I knew more about the car than all the sales people, all except for one, and he's the one I bought the 09 Sport Navi 5spd from (whenever it gets here).
I think if you've been driving auto's most of your life go with the auto, and vice versa. Whatever you're more comfortable.
I test drove the 2007 Fit way back in 2006 - July (Auto) , August (5spd & auto again for comparison). I can't get used to the paddles, and don't like the feel of the auto. The 5 speed is more to my liking, probably cause I've been mainly driving manual cars for 20yrs. To each his/her own.
I would have bought the 07 Fit but couldnt get the deal I wanted, and I was frustrated with the majority of the dealerships mistruths. Thanks to fitfreak.net I knew more about the car than all the sales people, all except for one, and he's the one I bought the 09 Sport Navi 5spd from (whenever it gets here).
I think if you've been driving auto's most of your life go with the auto, and vice versa. Whatever you're more comfortable.
#7
I just drove 300 miles to pick up my new silver 09 Fit Sport MT. Couldn't find one locally with the manual (lots of AT though). After 5 years with a car with an auto, it was time to go back. Shifts very nicely, and seems a good match for the engine.
MT vs AT is always a matter of personal preference. I just like manuals better, even though it means I now have to teach my wife to shift.
MT vs AT is always a matter of personal preference. I just like manuals better, even though it means I now have to teach my wife to shift.
#8
09 Fit's equipped with the manual seem to rev 1000+RPM's higher than the auto at highway speeds - this was the deal killer for me as I drive 90% highway. I was going 65 in 5th gear, I forget the exact RPM of each but there was a difference of over 1000 rpm's, therefore the engine was louder/more noticeable with the manual...just one thing to consider if you prefer a more quiet ride on the highway.
Last edited by reako; 10-10-2008 at 11:44 AM.
#9
Engine does rev a bit with the manual. I was pulling a bit over 3500 at 75 on the freeway drive back from the dealer. Didn't sound too bad, though, and Honda engines are known to be a bit revvy. Still should have gotten around 40 MPG, so no complaints.
Then again, my last motorcycle cruised at 6000 rpm (redline at 9,500) so I'm used to higher numbers.
Then again, my last motorcycle cruised at 6000 rpm (redline at 9,500) so I'm used to higher numbers.
#11
well there is hope, the honda insight (the first 3 dr crx-looking one) was stick
#13
Even though they are getting better on the making auto tranny (a tad smoother now) nothing beats the control and feel of MT.
But you might want to consider your driving condition when making the decision.
If you do long commute on heavy traffic it will be less tiring with Auto.
It (auto) might be easier to sell too.
The drawback for long term is auto tranny will be more expensive to fix than MT.
But you might want to consider your driving condition when making the decision.
If you do long commute on heavy traffic it will be less tiring with Auto.
It (auto) might be easier to sell too.
The drawback for long term is auto tranny will be more expensive to fix than MT.
#15
first things first you have to decide for yourself.
but here is my way of looking at this.
first you have to think.
do i do more city or highway driveing?
i did 90% highway. so it was a no brainer.
auto for me.
the auto revs lower than the manual.
now mind you i love manuals i even ordered one.
but when i found out there was new gear ratios
and the manual was going to be reving higher on the
highway i changed my order to automatic.
so my way of looking at it if you do alot of city driving
go for the manual.
if you do alot of highway get the auto.
i also love these paddle shifters. just put the car is S
and it drives like a stick anyway. just the clutch is missing.
#16
I don't think a comparison strictly on rpms is right. Apples and oranges in my opinion. If they were directly comparable then we would see a drastic difference in EPA estimates between AT and MT. There are also more drivetrain losses in the AT. Feel free to tell me I am wrong... I could be.
#17
The way I see it...
Go manual, or go home!
I don't care how much highway driving you do, manual will always afford you more control over the car, especially in emergency situations.
I'm really going to miss manual when most cars are electric (ie. transmission-less) :/
Go manual, or go home!
I don't care how much highway driving you do, manual will always afford you more control over the car, especially in emergency situations.
I'm really going to miss manual when most cars are electric (ie. transmission-less) :/
#18
It does matter on your preference. I use my fit as my daily driver and I driver over 100miles a day and with the traffic here in LA I choose the auto for the convenience. Don't get me wrong I love manual cars which why I still have my 5spd coupe for the weekends It all depends on the driver and situation.
#20
However, this sport shift is better than the versions by other manufacturers.
Most manufacturers you have the shift override on or off. This car is always on--even when it is in regular drive, you can still override the shifting by using the paddles. Then, if you put it in manual mode, you control when it shifts... It will downshift when you stop, but I think that is all it will do.
So, in short--I'm a manual driver that is pleased and enjoying my AT with sport shifting.
Without sport shifting paddles? NFW.
Best of luck with your decision.